Welcome

Thank you for visiting 2nd First Look! Check out our latest post on our Home page. You can also read dozens of more articles on film, television, music, literature, gaming, and the arts by clicking on the designated buttons. We'd love to hear your opinions so make sure to leave comments!

2011/09/19

Saving Fish From Drowning

By Lisa Adamowicz Kless


Amy Tan introduces her novel Saving Fish From Drowning with a story from "real life": how she wandered into a New York library to escape bad weather one day and found the material for the book as she passed the time.  Or, so many readers thought; later, people began to look into the supposedly true events and people that inspired the novel, and many cried foul when they couldn’t substantiate Tan’s claims.  There are websites with comment after comment from readers, lamenting that they feel duped by the author.  I‘ll freely admit that I was one of those readers who took the opening story at face value, but I’m more inclined to say “bravo” to Ms. Tan.  Having read some of her other work and already knowing what a talented storyteller she is, her “sleight of hand” on the page gives me more admiration for her as a fellow writer.  It’s not always easy to draw readers in to your work and interweave multiple plot lines, and Tan’s possibly faux preface does both things exceedingly well.


The novel revolves around a quirky socialite and art dealer named Bibi Chen and a group of her well-to-do friends who are planning a holiday time trip to China and Myanmar.  After making the arrangements for their adventure and designating herself as tour guide, Bibi dies unexpectedly and mysteriously.  Brand new to the afterlife, she still goes along with the group, trying to figure out how to navigate her new existence along the way.  Despite Bibi’s sudden passing, her friends go forward with the vacation, justifying it by asserting that Bibi would’ve wanted them to forge ahead.  Tan’s use of Bibi as a wacky, unreliable storyteller is pure fun.  What follows is a winding, complex comedy of errors that culminates with the group disappearing into a jungle on Christmas Day.
Amy Tan

Though this isn’t a quick read (it has 474 pages), the commentary from Bibi Chen throughout amps up the adventure.  Sometimes sarcastic and always opinionated, Bibi gives us glimpses into the characters' faults, attributes and frailties.  It’s through these insights from Bibi that characters who seem a little bit cloying on the surface are given more depth, and we can even empathize.  While much of the novel is somewhat light-hearted and funny, political commentary, misunderstandings (and just plain ignorance) of other cultures and beliefs also play a large part in the storyline.  There were a few characters that I would have liked to have seen expanded on even more, and some reactions from the characters that seemed rather unrealistic considering the circumstances.  All in all though, this novel maintained a perfect record: there hasn't yet been a book from Amy Tan that I haven't enjoyed. 

2 comments:

  1. It's not just in the foreword where Amy Tan lies about the story being true. In the "Thanks to" page at the back of the book, some of the characters from the story are listed.

    Fiction should stand on its own merits. I feel Amy Tan crossed the line. To put it another way, the story on its own, without the added spice of the reader wondering if it is true, isn't a particularly good one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Though I disagree about it not being a good story, before I wrote the piece for this website, I read many comments on blogs where people felt very strongly about Tan's tactic of presenting the backstory as if it really happened. If anything, it definitely provokes an opinion and discussion...

    ReplyDelete